Advice for Managing Mediocre Employees

This is Laura Lee Rose, a business and efficiency coach that specializes in professional development, time management, project management and work-life balance strategies. In my Professional Development Toolkit package , I go into professional development and real-world IT topics in detail. If you are interested in more training in these areas, get signed up

Mediocre employees are the most frustrating because they’re the ones who aren’t bad enough to reprimand, but they’re far from
being superstars either. What are some tips for motivating the mediocre?

Well – my recommendation is to simply eliminate “Mediocre Employees”.

Step 1: The most efficient method is to set your job performance criteria such that you are pleased with everyone that meets those criteria. The performance criteria need to be directly tied to the company’s vision, mission, and goals. Those that fall below those performance criteria are ‘below expectations’ and are eventually placed on a PIP (performance improvement plan).

Clearly outline the company’s business goals. Then each department executives clearly outline their individual performance business commitments (PBC – or things they are responsible for doing) to meet the company’s business goals (which are appropriate and directly connected to their department). Then each manager below each department outlines their PBC for their role/responsibilities/department — what will achieve and accomplish their upper managements’ business goal. Then each employee writes their PBC that supports and accomplish their manager’s PBC. These PBC’s are then detailed into SMART goals (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Realistic, and Time-bound goals). SMART goals have very tangibly and visible results (either your passed or failed on your goals).

If you and your team have done your job in clearly articulating and supporting your quality objectives and performance business expectations, then even those that merely meet your expectations (average employees) – are still doing acceptable work in helping the company reach it’s goal — because – after all — you have defined your quality standards and business commitments. If you are not satisfied with their work – then chances are that you have not clearly or effectively conveyed your expectations and business goals. Remember – if you are ‘wishy-washy’ on your expectations, you will get ‘wishy-washy’ performances.

My Professional Development Toolkit DVD discusses all of this in more detail. Contact LauraRose@RoseCoaching.info for more information on how to get this kit.

Step 2: Make an effort to match the employee’s career goals, skills and passions with the right job or role. If the role/responsibilities are aligned with what the employee wants to accomplish in the long run, the employee will be inspired and can’t help themselves from doing a terrific job. It’s more of a calling for them than a job.

Conduct frequent one-on-one meetings with your employees to discover their career goals, skills and passions. Direct them to roles and responsibilities that align the employee with both their goals and your company’s business goals. Show them the career path and required skill-set that they need to acquire to achieve their career goals. This might mean a change of departments. This might mean some additional certification and training. But this might also mean that they end up leaving the company because (through these one-on-one meetings) the employee realizes that their career goals do not match the company’s path.

My Professional Development Toolkit DVD discusses all of this in more detail. Contact LauraRose@RoseCoaching.info for more information on how to get this kit.

Step 3) Make the employee fully responsible for their own career. It’s not the manager or company’s responsibility that the employee has a satisfying work-life balance. It’s not the manager or company’s responsibility that the employee is happy at their job. It’s not the manager or company’s responsibility that the employee gets along with his/her coworkers or managers. It’s the employee’s profession; it’s the employee’s career. The manager or company can do is to support the employee in their career goals (through frequent one-on-one meetings with their employees). But the manager or company isn’t responsible for the employee’s career. The employee needs to take full ownership of designing their own career and life.

My Professional Development Toolkit DVD discusses all of this in more detail. Contact LauraRose@RoseCoaching.info for more information on how to get this kit.

In my Professional Toolkit, I provide worksheet, templates and guidance on how to accomplish these things. In my Book of Answers: Companion piece to the Professional Toolkit, I have 100 work-life scenarios like the above. The scenarios show how to accomplish your goals in similar situation.
For more information on how to get this toolkit or the “Book of Answers”, please contact:

vConferenceOnline.com/Bits on the Wire, Inc.
6420 E. Broadway, Suite A300
Tucson, AZ 85710
520-760-2400 or (877) 853-9158
info@vconferenceonline.com

Try it and let me know what you think.